It is fair to say that P2P investing (also known as crowdlending/crowdfunding) is gaining popularity worldwide. As the banking industry continue to provide low to negative interest rates for people putting their money into saving accounts, and with many predicting a bear market for stocks and recession in the near future, people are starting to look for alternative ways to invest. P2P investing has emerged as a viable alternative for those with just a little spare cash and others with millions to invest and want to diversify their portfolios. We have listed below some of the pros and cons of investing in the P2P industry:
- High Returns
The number one draw for the asset class is the high returns it offers. Most platforms average around 13% p/a, and it is possible to invest in individual projects that are a lot higher. We have even seen investment opportunities offering returns up to 26%! With the magic of compound interest and rates this high, it would take just 3 years to double your investment. A note of caution however – Investment returns this high are simply not sustainable in the long term and come with a high degree of risk – see points listed in our risk section below.
You might ask yourself why would a business or person taking out a loan pay interest rates this high? The answer is usually a combination of various reasons surrounding ease, time and other. P2P platforms offer a number of advantages over traditional banks, such as:
- Same day credit decisions
- Less paperwork involved
- Short term loans (bridging finance)
- Marketing opportunities
This provides opportunities for investors to make significant returns by cutting out the traditional middle man (i.e the bank) and businesses can take out loans with short notice – A win win for the investor and businesses.
- Passive Income
Many platforms have an auto invest feature – a very effective tool that allows you to set up your investment strategy to automatically invest for you based on specific criteria that suit your investment style. Depending on the platform this could be a very sophisticated strategy where investments are made only after a number of criteria are met, or else a simple strategy where you just select the interest rate you want. Either way, this feature is extremely powerful as it allows you to earn returns with little time needed to evaluate loans individually. Once you have the tool set up, you can sit back and watch the money come in, checking in every once and a while.
- Investing local
Most P2P platforms source their investments from their local market. So when you invest in the platform, it is likely that you are helping the local market grow or are supporting a local person that needs a loan for a new car, house, etc. This works well for businesses aswel – by listing themselves on the platform they can have thousands of investors feeling part of a new business project or initiative and investors will be more likely to spend money on this business.
Some of our favourite investments have been investing in an Irish whiskey company and providing a loan to a 72 year old Romanian woman to buy a new car. What other asset classes provide these kind of opportunities??
- Liquidity of Investments
Some (and we stress only some!) platforms provide an opportunity for investors to sell their loans back to the platform through a secondary market or selling directly to the platform itself, with a fee. Other platforms provide invest and access features where you can access the money invested almost immediately with the click of a button.
Investors with a short term investment horizon or those that feel they may need immediate access to their funds in the near future should concentrate their investments on platforms with these features. However, they usually come with a cost – investment returns are (generally) lower.
- Invest in secured assets
Investing in business loans can sometimes come with an additional layer of security – the loans can be secured against collateral provided by the borrower. This means that in the event the borrower cannot repay the loan for whatever reason and they default, the lender can take the asset and sell it in order to recover the debts. Not an ideal scenario – but it does provide an additional layer of protection for investors.
“The only investors who shouldn’t diversify are those who are right 100% of the time.”
P2P is a relatively new asset class that provides investment opportunities outside of the usual stocks, bonds, property, etc investments. Anyone that follows this blog knows that we know that we will never be right 100% of the time! We aim to diversify our risk by investing in multiple (hopefully uncorrelated) asset classes. This is investing 101 – Spread your risk around by investing in more than one loan originator and more than one asset class. When one is under-performing, hopefully another will help balance things out.
- High Risk
P2P is a new asset class. It is yet unproven to see how it will perform in a recession. Will people and businesses stop paying back their loans or will it result in more people taking out loans and boost returns overall? The lack of a track record makes it hard to forecast the future, only time will tell.
Either way, it is fair to say that there is a very real risk of losing a significant proportion of the money invested, and that investors should employ strategies to reduce their risk exposure. We’ve outlined a few here that could come in handy:
|RISK||WHAT THIS IS||STRATEGY TO REDUCE RISK|
|Portfolio Risk||Every P2P platform starts finding itself in trouble||– Invest in stocks, gold, bonds, ETF’s, Index funds, etc|
|Platform Risk||One specific P2P platform finds itself in trouble||– Invest in several platforms|
– Review financial statements to assess long term viability of company
– Check out Brismo site to gauge investor confidence in the platform
|Loan Selection Risk||The loan you’ve selected is not repaid||– Only invest in loans that come with a buyback guarantee|
– Diversify by investing a max of 10 euro in each loan
|Loan originator selection risk||The loan originator listed on the P2P platform goes out of business||– Invest in loan originators that score about 50 in our table|
– Spread your investments across minimum 20 loan originators
|Group Guarantee Risk||One particular entity for the loan originator goes out of business, while the rest of the business carries on as normal||– Same as above|
– Invest in loan originators that have a group guarantee or stand alone entities with a solid financial performance.
|Black Swan Events||All other events||Be ready to react. Accept event if you can’t do anything and move on!|
- Liquidity of investments
Most P2P platforms (particularly business loans) require investors to put their capital away for several months, or even years. In some cases withdrawing capital is not possible, in others it is possible but can come at a fee for investors.
- Transparency of data
While some platforms try to be upfront and transparent about Loan Originators listed on their platform (kudos to you, Mintos!) – Others do not provide enough data for investors to really understand the risk of their investments and fully evaluate the opportunities listed. The industry as a whole is improving thanks to pressure from investors, so hopefully this continues over the next few years. However, at the minute it is fair to say that investors need to take a leap of faith for some opportunities presented to them – not an ideal scenario for those looking to steadily build their wealth.
- Cash drag (no investment opportunities)
The more popular platforms are attracting investors quicker than people/businesses seeking investments, and demand is exceeding supply. For some platforms, opportunities are fully invested in within minutes and this leads to cash sitting on the sidelines for some time. Other platforms only have loans listed with a relatively low return as loans with high returns are snapped up immediately. Investors need to be on the lookout for opportunities and ready to invest when the time comes in order to reduce their cash drag and boost returns.
Well there you have it – the pros and cons of the P2P industry. There are countless more pros and cons that we could have included, but these are the most important for us. Overall we really do like the P2P industry – it is a unique asset class that allows investors with little cash to make some real returns and start their investing journey.
For platform specific guides why not check out some of our other reviews, linked below. You can help support us by using the sign up links below – some of these will also boost your returns:
|Platform Review||About||Average Return||Sign Up Bonus!|
|Mintos||Mintos is the largest P2P platform in Europe and was established in 2015. Company operations based in Riga, Latvia.||12.5%||1% of average balance for first 90 days|
|Grupeer||Grupeer is a P2P platform that was registered in 2016, launching in February 2017. Company operations are based in Riga Latvia. Grupeer offer two types of loans; loans issued by credit institutions to individuals and loans issued to enterprises.||13.5%||No Bonus currently|
|Flender||Flender is an Irish P2P platform founded in 2015, offering investment opportunities to businesses based in Ireland.||10.5%||5% of all investments made in first 30 days|
|Crowdestor||Crowdestor is a Latvian based P2P Platform offering high returns for investments in business loans||17%||<Coming soon>|
|Degiro||Degiro is an online trading platform offering incredibly low rates for stock investing||NA||20 euro|
|Currencyfair||Currencyfair is an online currency exchange platforms offering rates far more favourable than traditional banks||NA||30 euro once 1,000 euro transferred|